2016 Ford Taurus vs 2009 Toyota Corolla vs 2015 Buick Encore
Reliability Side-by-Side
2016
Ford Taurus
Grade C+
A comfortable cruiser that can be a solid value, but critical powertrain components require vigilant attention and proactive maintenance.
2009
Toyota Corolla
Grade A-
A supremely dependable and economical compact car, provided you're diligent about checking engine oil.
2015
Buick Encore
Grade C+
A comfortable compact SUV, but the 1.4L engine's Achilles' heel demands vigilant maintenance.
Best For
Best for Reliability
2009 Toyota Corolla
Score 88/100 vs 78/100
Best for Lowest Risk
2009 Toyota Corolla
low risk
Best for Lowest Annual Upkeep
2009 Toyota Corolla
$300-500
Autojunket OSC · OSC Transfer
Sell your car for what it's worth.
Log every service. Sell with a signed PDF. Every receipt, mileage-verified, in the buyer's hands.
Cost of Ownership
| Line Item | 2016 Ford Taurus | 2009 Toyota Corolla★ | 2015 Buick Encore |
|---|---|---|---|
| Annual Maintenance | $500-700 | $300-500 | $400-600 |
| Moderate Repairs | $500-1,500 occasionally (e.g., control arms, electrical diagnosis) | $400-800 occasionally (e.g., O2 sensor, control arm bushings) | $500-1,500 occasionally |
| MPG (City/Hwy) | 19 / 27 | 26 / 34 | 25 / 33 |
| MSRP (New) | $27,110 | $15,350 | $24,070 |
Major-failure risk and insurance outlook for each vehicle are in their full reliability reports.
Biggest Risks on Each
2016 Ford Taurus
Transmission (6F50/6F55)
60,000-120,000 mi
Power Transfer Unit (PTU) - AWD Models
70,000-110,000 mi
Engine Water Pump (3.5L Duratec V6)
90,000-150,000 mi
2009 Toyota Corolla
Engine Oil Consumption
60,000-120,000 mi
Steering System
40,000-90,000 mi
Body/Underbody Rust
80,000-150,000 mi
2015 Buick Encore
Engine (1.4L Turbo)
40,000-80,000 mi
Cooling System
60,000-100,000 mi
Electrical/Sensors
50,000-90,000 mi
Get the Full Report on Each
7-system breakdown, mileage danger zones, repair costs, and expert verdict for each vehicle.
Free · Instant delivery · No account required
Autojunket
Free
per report
Carfax
$44.99
per report
OSC
$9.99/mo
unlimited
Not sure yet? See a real, unblurred sample report →
Editorial Take
Comparing a 2016 Ford Taurus, a 2009 Toyota Corolla, and a 2015 Buick Encore might seem unusual at first glance, as they represent vastly different vehicle segments and model years. However, these vehicles often find themselves in consideration by used car buyers with varying priorities and budgets, particularly those looking for reliable transportation within a similar price range on the secondary market. A buyer might be weighing the spaciousness and power of a full-size sedan, the absolute economy and bulletproof reliability of a compact sedan, or the elevated driving position and modern amenities of a subcompact SUV. Key decision factors among these three include initial purchase price, long-term running costs, passenger and cargo capacity, driving dynamics, and the level of technology and comfort features offered. HEAD-TO-
Reliability & Common Issues
2016 Ford Taurus: 1. Power Transfer Unit (PTU) leaks or failures: Particularly common on AWD models, the PTU can develop fluid leaks or outright fail, requiring expensive repairs, often seen between 60,000 and 100,000 miles. 2. Water pump failures: On 3.5L V6 engines, the internal water pump can fail, leading to coolant leaks and potential engine damage. Replacement is labor-intensive, often requiring engine removal, making it a costly repair for vehicles past warranty. 3. MyFord Touch/Sync infotainment glitches: Owners report issues with system freezing, slow response, or connectivity problems, which can be frustrating but typically do not affect vehicle operation. 2009 Toyota Corolla: 1. Excessive oil consumption: While less prevalent than in earlier generations, some 1.8L engines from this era can exhibit higher-than-normal oil consumption, requiring frequent checking and topping off, especially as mileage approaches 100,000. 2. Loose steering shaft bolts: A known issue where bolts connecting the intermediate steering shaft can loosen, leading to clunking noises or a loose feeling in the steering. A Technical Service Bulletin (TSB) was issued for this. 3. Dashboard cracks: A widespread cosmetic issue for many Toyota models of this vintage, where the dashboard material develops cracks over time, particularly in hot climates. 2015 Buick Encore: 1. Turbocharger issues: Some owners report problems with the 1.4L turbocharger, including wastegate actuator malfunctions or oil leaks, typically occurring after 70,000-100,000 miles. 2. IntelliLink infotainment glitches: Similar to other systems of its era, the IntelliLink unit can sometimes suffer from slow response, frozen screens, or Bluetooth connectivity issues. 3. HVAC blend door actuator failures: Failures in these actuators can lead to inconsistent cabin temperature control or clicking noises from behind the dashboard.
Value & Cost of Ownership
When considering these vehicles on the used market, their value propositions shift significantly from their new MSRPs. A 2016 Ford Taurus might be found for $10,000 to $20,000+, depending on trim, mileage, and condition. A 2009 Toyota Corolla will likely range from $6,000 to $10,000. The 2015 Buick Encore typically falls in the $9,000 to $15,000+ bracket. Insurance costs for the Corolla are generally the lowest due to its lower power and cost of repair. The Encore's insurance costs are typically moderate, while the Taurus, especially the powerful SHO model, can command higher premiums. Maintenance costs for the Corolla are renowned for being very low, with affordable parts and widespread technician familiarity. The Encore's maintenance costs are moderate for its class, with the turbocharged engine potentially requiring slightly more specialized care. The Taurus can have moderate maintenance costs for routine service, but the potential for expensive repairs like PTU or water pump issues, as mentioned earlier, can significantly increase long-term ownership costs for certain examples. Resale value is a strong point for the Toyota Corolla, which consistently holds its value exceptionally well, making it a wise investment even as a used vehicle. The Buick Encore also demonstrates solid resale value within the growing crossover segment. The Ford Taurus, while a competent sedan, tends to depreciate more rapidly than its competitors, especially in the used market for full-size sedans.
Editorial Verdict
Best for families: The 2016 Ford Taurus. Its expansive interior, large trunk, and generally strong safety ratings make it the most suitable choice for transporting a family comfortably. The available AWD offers added security in adverse weather. Best for commuters: The 2009 Toyota Corolla. Its exceptional fuel economy, legendary reliability, and minimal running costs make it the ultimate commuter car for those prioritizing efficiency and worry-free ownership over features or performance. Best for enthusiasts: The 2016 Ford Taurus SHO. With its potent twin-turbo V6 engine, all-wheel drive, and sport-tuned suspension, the SHO variant offers thrilling acceleration and a surprisingly engaging drive for a large sedan. The other trims are not typically considered enthusiast vehicles. Best value overall: The 2009 Toyota Corolla. While it lacks modern features and performance, its rock-bottom purchase price on the used market, incredibly low running costs, and virtually indestructible reliability deliver unparalleled long-term value. For those seeking a more modern feel and elevated driving position, the 2015 Buick Encore offers excellent value, blending compact dimensions with premium touches and respectable fuel economy, making it a compelling choice for urban dwellers who want something newer than the Corolla but still budget-friendly.
Parts & Accessories for These Vehicles
Products for 2016 Ford Taurus
Products for 2009 Toyota Corolla
Products for 2015 Buick Encore
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.