2016 Ford Taurus vs 2009 Toyota Corolla
Reliability Side-by-Side
2016
Ford Taurus
Grade C+
A comfortable cruiser that can be a solid value, but critical powertrain components require vigilant attention and proactive maintenance.
2009
Toyota Corolla
Grade A-
A supremely dependable and economical compact car, provided you're diligent about checking engine oil.
Best For
Best for Reliability
2009 Toyota Corolla
Score 88/100 vs 72/100
Best for Lowest Risk
2009 Toyota Corolla
low risk
Best for Lowest Annual Upkeep
2009 Toyota Corolla
$300-500
Autojunket OSC · OSC Transfer
Sell your car for what it's worth.
Log every service. Sell with a signed PDF. Every receipt, mileage-verified, in the buyer's hands.
Cost of Ownership
| Line Item | 2016 Ford Taurus | 2009 Toyota Corolla★ |
|---|---|---|
| Annual Maintenance | $500-700 | $300-500 |
| Moderate Repairs | $500-1,500 occasionally (e.g., control arms, electrical diagnosis) | $400-800 occasionally (e.g., O2 sensor, control arm bushings) |
| MPG (City/Hwy) | 18 / 27 | 26 / 34 |
| MSRP (New) | $27,110 | $15,350 |
Major-failure risk and insurance outlook for each vehicle are in their full reliability reports.
Biggest Risks on Each
2016 Ford Taurus
Transmission (6F50/6F55)
60,000-120,000 mi
Power Transfer Unit (PTU) - AWD Models
70,000-110,000 mi
Engine Water Pump (3.5L Duratec V6)
90,000-150,000 mi
2009 Toyota Corolla
Engine Oil Consumption
60,000-120,000 mi
Steering System
40,000-90,000 mi
Body/Underbody Rust
80,000-150,000 mi
Get the Full Report on Each
7-system breakdown, mileage danger zones, repair costs, and expert verdict for each vehicle.
Free · Instant delivery · No account required
Autojunket
Free
per report
Carfax
$44.99
per report
OSC
$9.99/mo
unlimited
Not sure yet? See a real, unblurred sample report →
Editorial Take
Comparing a 2016 Ford Taurus with a 2009 Toyota Corolla is an interesting exercise in contrasts, showcasing the divergent philosophies of a large American full-size sedan versus a compact Japanese economy car from different eras. While not direct competitors in their respective new car markets, they often appear on the used car market for buyers seeking affordable, reliable transportation or spacious, feature-rich cruisers. Those considering the Taurus typically prioritize interior space, a comfortable ride, and available power and technology. Corolla buyers, conversely, lean towards exceptional fuel economy, renowned long-term reliability, and a lower overall cost of ownership. Key decision factors revolve around size, budget, daily driving needs, and the importance of modern amenities versus proven simplicity. HEAD-TO-
Reliability & Common Issues
2016 Ford Taurus: 1. Water Pump Issues: The 3.5L V6 engine (non-EcoBoost) has a known design flaw where the water pump is internally mounted within the timing chain cover. If it fails, coolant can leak directly into the engine oil, potentially causing severe engine damage. Repair often requires significant labor, including engine or timing cover removal. This issue typically manifests after 60,000-80,000 miles. 2. MyFord Touch/Sync System Glitches: The optional MyFord Touch infotainment system, common in this era of Ford vehicles, was prone to software bugs, freezing, slow response times, and connectivity issues. While software updates helped, the system's overall performance could be frustrating for owners. 3. Power Transfer Unit (PTU) Leaks/Failure (AWD models): On all-wheel-drive Taurus models, the Power Transfer Unit (which sends power to the rear wheels) can develop fluid leaks or outright failure due to heat and insufficient fluid capacity. This is a costly repair that can affect models at various mileages, particularly those that are not serviced regularly. 2009 Toyota Corolla: 1. Excessive Oil Consumption: Some 1.8L 2ZR-FE engines in the 2009 Corolla can exhibit higher-than-normal oil consumption, especially as they accumulate mileage (often beyond 70,000-100,000 miles). This is generally due to piston ring design and can lead to low oil levels if not monitored, potentially causing engine damage. Regular oil level checks and topping off are crucial. 2. Dashboard Melting/Cracking: A widespread issue for Toyota vehicles of this era, the dashboard material can become sticky, soft, or develop cracks due to prolonged exposure to sunlight and heat. This is a cosmetic issue but can be unsightly and expensive to repair. Toyota issued a warranty enhancement for some models, but it has likely expired. 3. VVT-i Actuator Rattle: A common complaint is a brief rattle or knocking noise from the engine on cold start-up, often attributed to the Variable Valve Timing with intelligence (VVT-i) actuator. While generally not indicative of catastrophic failure, it can be an annoying characteristic.
Value & Cost of Ownership
When purchased new, the 2016 Ford Taurus was significantly more expensive, with an MSRP starting around $27,000, while the 2009 Toyota Corolla started closer to $15,000. On the used market today, a 2016 Taurus can range from approximately $8,000 to $15,000 depending on trim, mileage, and condition, with SHO models at the higher end. A 2009 Toyota Corolla typically sells for between $4,000 and $8,000, reflecting its age and lower initial price. Insurance costs for the Corolla are generally lower due to its smaller engine, lower replacement cost, and often better safety ratings for its class. The Taurus, particularly the more powerful V6 and SHO models, will typically incur higher insurance premiums. Maintenance costs for the Corolla are generally lower due to its simpler engineering, widespread availability of inexpensive parts, and Toyota's reputation for mechanical robustness. Common maintenance items are usually straightforward and affordable. The Taurus, especially models with the EcoBoost engines or AWD, can have more complex and potentially more expensive repairs, particularly if the common issues like water pump or PTU failure occur. Resale value is where the Corolla truly shines; it historically holds its value exceptionally well, especially older models known for their reliability. While the Taurus depreciates more quickly in absolute terms, its used price allows for acquiring a large, feature-rich car for a relatively low initial investment. However, percentage-wise, the Corolla retains more of its value over time.
Editorial Verdict
Best for families: The 2016 Ford Taurus is the superior choice for families due to its immense interior space, cavernous trunk (20.1 cubic feet), and a wider array of available safety and comfort features like blind-spot monitoring and adaptive cruise control. Its larger size provides a more secure feel on the highway. Best for commuters: The 2009 Toyota Corolla excels as a commuter car. Its excellent fuel economy (up to 26 city / 35 highway MPG), compact size for easy parking, and legendary reliability make it a low-stress and inexpensive daily driver. Best for enthusiasts: For enthusiasts, the 2016 Ford Taurus SHO is the clear winner. With 365 horsepower from its twin-turbo V6 and standard all-wheel drive, it offers strong acceleration and confident handling that the economical Corolla cannot match. The standard V6 Taurus, while less exhilarating, still provides a more engaging drive than the Corolla. Best value overall: The 2009 Toyota Corolla arguably offers the best overall value. While it lacks the features and space of the Taurus, its significantly lower purchase price, exceptional fuel economy, notoriously low maintenance costs, and superior long-term reliability mean it will likely cost far less to own and operate over many years. For those prioritizing long-term dependability and minimal running costs, the Corolla remains a smart, enduring choice.
Parts & Accessories for These Vehicles
Products for 2016 Ford Taurus
Products for 2009 Toyota Corolla
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.